Ten years after the UK stumbled into a rushed public vote that divided the nation and caused disorder, a warning emerges from beyond the Irish Sea: it could happen again.
Authorities and electorate drifted into Brexit and the same could occur with a national vote on a unified Ireland, initiating upheavals for which no one is equipped.
That is the message from two respected writers from each side of the Irish border who have collaborated to examine the benefits and drawbacks of Northern Ireland leaving the UK to create a different country with the Republic of Ireland.
Political Establishments Not Ready
The author and columnist and Sam McBride, have found that the government bodies in Ireland and Britain are woefully unprepared for a possibly contentious and monumental referendum.
"The lesson of Brexit remains unheeded, which is that developments can emerge unexpectedly and can gather momentum very quickly," O’Toole said. "It is my view that the political architecture of our islands remains extremely volatile."
Book Publication Seeks to Encourage Dialogue
The team have studied the governmental, financial and societal reasons for any constitutional change in a publication, The Case For and Against Unification, released by the Dublin-based Royal Irish Academy.
They aim to encourage dialogue on the matter with a roadshow of speaking events that will bring them to Westminster early next month.
"What haunts everyone, or ought to concern everybody, is the Brexit referendum of 2016," commented O’Toole.
"We should prevent a referendum on a thumbs up-thumbs down, unclear proposal whose consequences have remained undefined because then you find yourself with an extraordinarily polarised community where those defeated are resistant to losing and the people who have won are uncertain exactly what it is that they have achieved."
Governmental Mandate
Under the Belfast Agreement, the Northern Ireland government minister should call a public vote on Irish unity if it appears likely that a majority would support.
Nationalist parties and other pro-unification groups claim this point is looming, and a group called Ireland’s Future has rallied support, but both governments and pro-UK factions downplay the possibility, resulting in ambiguity whether or when there could be a national vote.
Absence of Serious Debate
Partisan language for and against unity has masked the absence of substantive discussion, stated the journalist.
"Many are supportive or opposed the notion but the actual thinking which may surpass that to make it possible has largely not occurred. A great deal has occurred in scholarly circles but scarcely any government figures or advocates are willing to participate with the fundamentals. As an example, which kind of country might be preferred? Unitary? Federal?"
Publication's Method
In the volume, no writer endorses unification or the current situation. Each writes two pieces that strive for neutrality in detailing the argument for a united Ireland and the argument opposing it, gathering economic and social data, historical precedents and structural examples.
Discussions encompass identity markers, taxes, healthcare systems, elderly benefits, public liabilities and the danger of pro-UK militancy. The aim is to inform and provoke conversation.
"Considerable attention exists in the topic but there is still lacking a dialogue," stated O’Toole. "Discussion suggests an recognition of the idea that there might be valid points on each side."
Dual Referendums
A public vote in Northern Ireland would also trigger one in the Republic of Ireland, where the electorate report they prefer unification but refuse increased taxation or adopting a new flag to acknowledge pro-UK communities' UK heritage.
"The Irish government should work out what the offer from pro-unification movements is aside from just saying: 'We want a unified Ireland and we value you'," remarked the commentator.
Probability of Referendum
The journalist thinks a national vote in his generation is possible and that it could happen abruptly. "It is possible just a mad or a bad or a negligent secretary of state who declares: 'Let us proceed and get it out of the way.'"
Each of the nationalists and unionists have credible, valid arguments, he commented. "One side will prevail here and somebody will in the end be defeated but all factions has got important lessons to learn from the alternative viewpoints."
Appeal for Wider Debate
Westminster should participate in the dialogue, urged O’Toole. "This involves the United Kingdom. It's a British issue equally as it is an Irish matter."